Analysing national responses to environmental and climate-related displacement.
A comparative assessment of Italian and French legal frameworks
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.57947/qrp.v61i1.22Keywords:
Climate Change, Disaster Displacement, Climate Refugees, Environmental Migration, Environment, Non-Refoulement, Complementary ProtectionAbstract
Interlinkages between climate change, environmental degradation and displacement have been widely recognized by academics and States. However, unlike other categories of forced migrants, environmental and climate-displaced people crossing an international border are not entitled to any ad hoc protection regime under current conventional law. Nevertheless, it has been argued that International Human Rights Law and, to a minor extent, International Refugee Law forbid the expulsion of those migrants who are unable to return to their country in dignity and safety due to environmental reasons.
While the role of International Law in dealing with environmental and climate-related displacement has been widely investigated by legal researchers, national immigration and asylum systems could be further examined.
This paper aims at examining the existing legal options for the protection of environmental and climate-related displaced persons under the Italian and French legal frameworks.
The Italian legal framework has been selected since it is characterized by two distinct kinds of complementary protection, both potentially addressing displacement induced by environmental hazards: the ‘special protection’ - which substituted the ‘humanitarian protection’ - and the ‘residence permit for calamity.
While no explicit reference is made to climate and environmental reasons in the French legal framework concerning the residence of third-country nationals, a recent judgement issued by the Bordeaux Appeal Court could pave the way for a gradual inclusion of such phenomena under the umbrella of the possible reasons justifying the issuance of a residence permit to those at risk of displacement for environmental and climate-related reasons.
Such a comparative analysis has the objective of giving a more practical thickness to the legal issues arising from environmental and climate-related displacement, including with the aim of identifying legal solutions to the new challenges posed by climate change and environmental degradation.
References
Apap, J. (2021). The concept of 'climate refugee': Towards a possible definition. European Parliamentary Research Service. https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/BRIE/2021/698753/EPRS_BRI(2021)698753_EN.pdf
Bendasdon, F. (2021). France’s first climate refugee: A sign of a promising future for climate migration? Earth Refuge. https://earthrefuge.org/frances-first-climate-refugee-a-sign-of-a-promising-future-for-climate-migration/
Benvenuti, M. (2019). Il dito e la luna. La protezione delle esigenze di carattere umanitario degli stranieri prima e dopo il decreto Salvini. Diritto, Immigrazione e Cittadinanza, (1), 1-40.
Biondi Dal Monte, F., & Rossi, E. (2021). Adelante con juicio: asilo e protezione degli stranieri dopo il D.l. n. 130/2020. Presentazione. Quaderni costituzionali, (1), 64-66.
Borges, I. M. (2019). Environmental change, forced displacement and international law: From legal protection gaps to protection solutions, Routledge.
Bourriez, D. (2022), Les défis de la détermination du statut de réfugiés par le HCR. Revue des droits de l’homme, 21.
Cantor, D. J. (2021). Environment, mobility, and international law: A new approach in the Americas. Chicago Journal of International Law, 21(2), 262-322.
Carbone, A. (2020, November 2), La nuova protezione speciale dello straniero ai sensi del D.l.130/20: eredità della vecchia protezione umanitaria? Altalex. https://www.altalex.com/documents/news/2020/11/02/nuova-protezione-speciale-straniero-ai-sensi-del-dl130-20-eredita-della-vecchia-protezione-umanitaria
Christian Aid. (2007). The human tide: The real migration crisis: https://www.christianaid.org.uk/sites/default/files/2017-08/human-tide-the-real-migration-crisis-may-2007.pdf
Conte, C. (2021). The uneven legal and policy framework facing persons with humanitarian status in Europe: Current gaps and possible solutions for improving integration policies. Migration Policy Group: https://www.migpolgroup.com/index.php/2021/11/29/new-in-depth-analysis-from-niem-highlights-the-uneven-quality-of-integration-laws-and-policies-for-humanitarian-status-holders/
Corsi, C. (2021). Il decreto legge n. 130/2020 tra continuità e cambiamento. Cenni introduttivi sui profili dell’immigrazione e dell’asilo. Quaderni costituzionali, (1), 67-75.
Cournil, C. (2005). Le statut interne de l’étranger et les normes supranationales. L’Harmattan Collection Logiques Juridiques, 744.
Cournil, C. (2007). Réflexion prospective sur une protection juridique des réfugiés écologiques. Revue Européenne des migrations internationales, 23(1), 7-34.
Cournil, C., & Mayer, B. (2015), Opportunités et limites d’une protection catégorielle au bénéfice des migrants environnementaux. In L. L. Jubilut & F. C. Fernandes Rei (Eds.), Les minorités environnementales, Université Catholique du Santos.
Geddes, A., Adger, W. N., Arnell, N., Black, R., & Thomas, D. S. G. (2012). Migration, environmental change, and the ‘challenges of governance. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy, 30(6), 951-967.
Gonin P., & Lassailly-Jacob, V. (2002). Les réfugiés de l’environnement. Une nouvelle catégorie de migrants forcés?. Revue Européenne des migrations Internationales, 18(2), 139-160.
Gouget, J. J. (2006). Réfugiés écologiques: Un débat controversé. Revue européenne de droit de l’environnement, 4, 381-399.
Government Office for Science. (2011). Foresight: Migration and global environmental change – Future Challenges and Opportunities. United Kingdom Government. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/287717/11-1116-migration-and-global-environmental-change.pdf
Hugo, G. (1996). Environmental concerns and international migration. The International Migration Review, 30(1), 105–131.
Hunter, L. M., & David, E. (2011). Displacement, climate change and gender. In E. Piguet, A. Pécoud, & P. De Guchteneire (Eds.), Migration and climate change. Cambridge University Press
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). (2014). Impacts, adaption and vulnerability: Regional aspects. Cambridge University Press.
Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre (IDMC) (2021). Global Report on Internal Displacement 2021. Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre. https://www.internal-displacement.org/sites/default/files/publications/documents/grid2021_idmc.pdf
Kraler, A., Katsiaficas, C., & Wagner, M. (2020). Climate change and migration. Legal and policy challenges and responses to environmentally induced migration. European Parliamentary Research Service: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/STUD/2020/655591/IPOL_STU(2020)655591_EN.pdf
Lecoutre, F. (2015), L'asile constitutionnel. In C., Laly-Chevalier, J., Fernandez (Eds.). Droit d'asile. État des lieux et perspective, Pedone
McAdam, J. (2007). Complementary protection in international refugee law. Oxford University Press.
McAdam, J. (2012). Climate change, forced migration, and international law. Oxford University Press.
McAdam, J. (2020). Protecting people displaced by the impacts of climate change: The UN Human Rights Committee and the principle of non-refoulement. American Journal of International Law, 114(4), 708-725.
McAdam, J. (2021). Displacement in the context of climate change and disasters, In C. Costello, M. Foster, & J. McAdam (Eds.), The Oxford Handbook of International Refugee Law, Oxford University Press, 832-847.
McLeman, R. A., Hunter, L. M. (2010). Migration in the context of vulnerability and adaption to climate change: Insights from analogues. Climate change, 1(3), 450-461.
Ministère de l'Intérieur (2017). Information du 29 janvier 2017 relative à l'application de la loi n° 2016-274 relative au droit des étrangers en France-dispositions relatives à la procédure de délivrance des documents de séjour et à la protection contre l'éloignement pour raison de santé, applicables à compter du 1er janvier 2017.
Ministère des Affaires sociales et de la Santé (2017), Arrêté du 5 janvier 2017 fixant les orientations générales pour l'exercice par les médecins de l'Office français de l'immigration et de l'intégration, de leurs missions, prévues à l'article L. 313-11 (11°) du code de l'entrée et du séjour des étrangers et du droit d'asile, article 3.
Mokhnacheva, D., & Gemenne, F. (2017). The Atlas of Environmental Migration. Routledge.
Morandi, N. (2020), Protezione internazionale, protezione speciale e nuove tipologie di permesso di soggiorno introdotte dal D.l. n. 113/2018. In F. Biondi Dal Monte, & E. Sommario (Eds.), Diritti oltre frontiera: Migrazioni, politiche di accoglienza e integrazione (pp. 189-214). Pisa University Press.
Morri, J. (2012). La protection juridictionnelle des droits sociaux comparée à celle des droits civils: Existe-t-il une réelle différence de mise en œuvre des droits? Revue des droits de l’homme, 1, 353-370.
Morrisey, J. (2009). Environmental change and forced migration: A state of the art review. Refugee Studies Centre Background Paper. http://www.rsc.ox.ac.uk/events/environmental-change-and-migration/EnvChangeandFmReviewWS.pdf
Myers, N. (1993). Environmental refugees in a globally warmed world: Estimating the scope of what could become a prominent international phenomenon. Bio Science, 43(11), 751-761.
National Commission for the Right to Asylum - Ministry of Interior (Commissione nazionale per il diritto di asilo – Ministero dell’Interno). (2015, July 30). Circular No. 3716/2015: Ipotesi in cui ricorrono i requisiti per il rilascio del permesso di soggiorno per motivi umanitari.
Perrini, F. (2021). Il riconoscimento della protezione umanitaria in caso di disastri ambientali nel recente orientamento della Corte di Cassazione. Rivista di Ordine Internazionale e Diritti umani, 349-362.
Piguet, E., (2008). Climate change and forced migration. New Issues in Refugee Research, No. 153.
Pinto, O., Lamine, H. (2001). Une vie familiale “subsidiaire”?, Plein Droit, (1-2)47/48, 12-14.
Ragheboom, H. (2017). The international legal status and protection of environmentally displaced persons: A European perspective. Brill.
Rossi, E. (2021). Novità in tema di permessi di soggiorno e protezione speciale nel D.l. n. 130 del 2020. Quaderni costituzionali, (1), 74-86.
Scott, M. (2014). Natural disasters, climate change and non-refoulement: What scope for resisting expulsion under Article 3 and 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights. International Journal of Refugee Law, 28(3), 404-436.
Scott, M. (2020). Climate change, disasters and the Refugee Convention. Cambridge University Press.
The Nansen Initiative. (2015). Agenda for the protection for cross-border displaced persons in the context of disasters and climate change. Volume I. https://disasterdisplacement.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/EN_Protection_Agenda_Volume_I_-low_res.pdf
Tower, A., & Plano, R. (2021). French court recognizes country’s first environmentally-impacted migrant. Climate Refugees. https://www.climate-refugees.org/spotlight/2021/1/15/french-court
Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHRC). (2012). Protecting people crossing borders in the context of climate change: Normative gaps and possible approaches. PPLA/2012/01.
Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR). (2020). Legal considerations regarding claims for international protection made in the context of the adverse effects of climate change and disasters. https://www.refworld.org/docid/5f75f2734.html
Veisse, A. (2006). Le médecin, la santé et le séjour des étrangers. Plein droit, 69(2), 32-35.
Zorzella, N. (2021), La nuova protezione speciale introdotta dal D.L.130/2020. Tra principio di flessibilità, resistenze amministrative e problematiche applicative. Diritto, Immigrazione e Cittadinanza, (2), 130-150.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
Categories
License
Copyright (c) 2022 Quarterly on Refugee Problems - AWR Bulletin
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
